Tuesday, August 24, 2010
Trentonian Article
Posted By Ersnt Kuglin and Barry Ellsworth – QMI Agency
Sound levels exploded when Mayor John Williams lost his temper, verbally attacking a constituent in a loud voice and slammed his open palm on the table during a meeting called to discuss a study about noise emenating from CB Freezers.
The normally affable Williams became incensed after goading Cliff White, a neighbour who lives just east of the Hwy. 33 plant, into admitting that after three years of battling to have the excessive noise levels controlled by the city, he no longer believed the mayor and city hall.
"You don't trust us?" Williams said in a loud voice, and he threatened to end the meeting, attended by about 30 people last week at city hall.
White, saying he was a taxpayer who deserved better treatment, stormed out of the room.
It was an explosive conclusion to the hour-long meeting, which broke up a few minutes after White's departure, with the promise that neighbours and CB Freezer management would meet in a few weeks time to further discuss the findings of the $18,000 noise study.
The meeting was not publicized by the city. In fact, it was White that notified The Trentonian the meeting was taking place at city hall.
"We didn't invite the world,'' said Williams in another exchange with White.
Williams has admitted to becoming "frustrated" in his bid to appease neighbours angry over the noise from a cooling tower and reefers running in transports to keep meat frozen at CB Freezers, located in the old FBI plant just west of the city limits in Murray ward, while trying to placate company management which is in the throes of expansion and has about 140 employees.
Neighours have complained bitterly that the mayor and city hall are putting jobs ahead of the quality of life for area residents, some of whom have put blankets over their windows to try to deaden the sound.
And the eight-page noise study, completed by J.E. Coulter Associates Ltd. of Toronto, proved the neighbours right — the sound is at times 60-to-80 per cent over the acceptable level of noise.
Coulter likened the sound, when it is at its peak from reefers, the loading dock and the cooling tower, to that of a Hercules aircraft flying over your house. But while the airplane noise lasts for a short time, the CB Freezer clamour can last hours.
"It's not gutwrenching (noise)," Coulter told the roomful of neighours, plant management owner Dale Willard and others, "(but) we found more noise than there should be."
The study contained three recommendations to bring the noise under regulation levels established by the Ministry of the Environment, including installation of silencers on the cooling tower, changing the parked and loaded trucks to face north, and perhaps build a noise barrier seven metres high (22 feet) high along the front property line of the plant. The last recommendation, Coulter conceded, would have to be more fully investigated because it could cause traffic problems for trucks entering and leaving the property on Highway 33.
Willard, who has built the company from two employees to a $70-million operation buying and selling meat on a global scale, said he was willing to be a "good corporate neighbour" and would take measures to control the noise.
"I think maybe there are some things we can do," he said. "We are not here to piss people off."
But the neighbours wonder why, then, have their complaints fallen on deaf ears for so long -- three families have sold their homes and moved after having their peace of mind, to say nothing of sleep, disrupted for years.
It appears the Ministry of the Environment will be called in since the noise levels are higher than the ministry's guidelines.
Williams said he was determined to fix the problem to the satisfaction of neighbours and the company.
On Monday, city CAO Gary Dyke, said the next step is to put a plan together in order to implement recommendations in the study.
"The process has already started,'' said Dyke.
But it's not known how much the noise abatement measures will cost CB Freezers. There's also growing speculation the city may share in the cost.
Mayor John Williams could not be reached for comment.
Saturday, August 7, 2010
Resident Update Submitted August 5th
John
Another beautiful evening, but I'm sure you're not putting up with the noise in the Oak Hills that we are putting up with on the Carrying Place Road. Two reefers running on high, sitting at the front of the factory making it impossible to enjoy the night.
When are we getting some results regarding the noise study?
As for the Ministry of the Environment and Lou Rinaldi, I have kept emails from both of you telling us that we do not have to put up with the noise and that no one can take away the enjoyment of our homes. Well, if you think any of us are enjoying this, think again. All Can is now running reefers and both of these factories are sitting in the middle of a residential area, regardless of how you have zoned it.
The XXXXX's, the XXXXX's and others to the east of us are complaining as well. How many home owners do you need to either move or put their homes up for sale. As a show of support I think all of us should put For Sale signs on our homes . It will bring the attention of the public to our situation. This has been going on for three years now and looking back on some of the correspondence I have had I actually have to laugh. The double talk and false promises are becoming too much.
Saturday, July 31, 2010
Resident Update Submitted Friday July 23rd
The Emperor has no clothes!
Tuesday, June 1, 2010
Resident Submission Sent May 30, 2010
Apparently All Can has installed a compressor or something of the sort. There is the same type of noise, and I don't think it comes from reefers, coming from the south east corner of their building. There has never been that noise until the noise study began. I go to work at the same place for the last 25 years and I'm pretty sure I would have picked up on it by now. If this is an attempt to derail the noise study then I would say it probably will succeed.
We hear very little from City Hall or Lou Rinaldi regarding what is going on but they were front and center for their photo opportunity at the expansion announcement for CB Freezers. These are our tax dollars that are going to support this expansion and the promise of jobs just doesn't cut it for me. We also pay taxes and when it comes to big business they seem to forget that. They have managed to escape the union by not rebuilding in Wellington. Adecco is supplying the manpower and all that means is the employees will be making low wages and really not helping our community at all. They will be able to survive but that is about it. After all they should be thankful to have a job or so I've heard.
This is an election year and all I can say is to make your disappointment known with your vote.
Monday, May 17, 2010
Resident Update Submitted May 15th, 2010
I spoke with Paul and Nicki after they had moved to their new home and Capital Movers commented that they knew about the noise issue as they have already moved another person from the road due to noise. Is that what is going to happen now, people are just going to move in and move out as they realize how noisy this plant is allowed to be?
What are they doing on the old rail bed in behind our properties. Is this going to increase truck traffic are they putting a road back there? Why now after the birds have become to nest and is that area nto parkland? How does this affect Hannah Park? We used to walk on that rail bed as I am sure lots of people with children and dogs do.
We need some answers. Once again I am trying to go to my own business and I haven't slept for most of the night.
Wednesday, May 12, 2010
Resident Update Submitted May 10, 2010
I believe that CB Freezers are doing things in order to mislead this investigation. For one thing, I have never heard continuous reefer noise coming from All Can directly across the road from Andjareenas Place, but in the last couple of weeks I have begun noticing a definate increase in noise. On Friday morning I left for work shortly after 5 a.m. and there were reefers running and the noise was definately coming from there. This week I also observed a reefer parked in the parking lot at the front of All Can parallel with hwy 33 and I haven't seen a reefer parked there in I don't know how long. Maybe years. The fact that these things are going on now that the noise study has begun makes me very concerned. Yes, we have our noise study but is it just smoke and mirrors?
I do not require an answer from you Mr. Mayor just keeping you up to date on what is going on.
Resident Update Submitted May 7, 2010
How is it ....I need a building permit to build a 10x12 shed or a 8x8 ft deck on my house, but these guys are allowed to build a "Cold Storage Facility" without approval by city council? Surely Gary Dyke must know something about this....he can't be that clueless or underhanded ......can he?
Thursday, May 6, 2010
Resident Update No. 3 Submitted May 6, 2010
Just my opinion
Resident Update No. 2 Submitted May 6, 2010
Considering that the sound engineers have been taking ambient noise levels this week I find this very suspicious. If base readings were taken near the AllCan factory wouldn't this increase our ambient noise levels, making the noise contamination from CB Freezers seem less severe? I certainly hope that residents in whatever area they have done the ambient sound readings in have been canvassed to see if there has been any unusual activity.
Resident Update Submitted May 6
This morning at 6:15 a.m. when I opened my kitchen windows I noticed that they have a reefer parked in the front parking lot, parallel with the highway. Again, it has been a very long time since they have done something like this.
Makes me wonder what's in it for them.
Friday, April 23, 2010
Resident Update 04/21/10
Monday, April 19, 2010
Resident Update Submitted 04/09/2010
John Williams has decided to run for mayor of Quinte West once again. I understand that Mr. Williams campaign is based on attracting new employers to the Quinte West area. I wish Mr. Williams would place as much emphasis on the people who live here. Jobs are important, but what about the workers? I am a worker. My husband is a worker. What good are we when we are so tired, stressed and worn that we cannot function properly? I have asked Mayor Williams for help, I have begged, my health has been affected as a direct
result of the noise issue, yet the bombardment continues.
I sincerely hope that the sound assessment done in May will result in positive action for the other residents here. I hope that everyone keeps their word and that this issue will be resolved. For us, it's too little too late and although it may not be much, we're taking our tax dollars elsewhere.
Sunday, April 11, 2010
Resident Update Submitted April 11, 2010
Monday, April 5, 2010
Resident Update April 5, 2010
A reefer was left to run continuously in the front loading area of CB Freezers for approximately 18 hours.
Multiple reefers were left in the front loading area to cycle on and off, to disrupt our family dinners, to disturb our sleep for the entire weekend.
Our Easter weekend has been filled with noise and torment and it continues still.
This past Easter weekend CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics have demonstrated the level of their commitment to mitigating the noise from their facility by disrupting the entire Easter weekend. With total disregard for us, their neighbors, they left reefers running in the front loading area for the entire weekend. Despite the fact that I took prescription medication in order to deal with the noise, in order to sleep in my own home, I was still woken up repeatedly by the noise coming from Chill Chain Logistics reefers left to drone in the front loading area of CB Freezers.
Resident Update April 3, 2010
My real fear is that if we have any change in government, both local and provincial, we will be starting all over again.
I'm sure they would embrace the change. It would allow them to continue to disrupt our lives.
Resident Update April 1, 2010
Depression and desperation begin to become a regular way of life after awhile. I need to sleep for my health.
Thursday, April 1, 2010
Resident Update Submitted March 27, 2010
Are you kidding me? Dust? We, on the Carrying Place Road have been sucking up the dust from CB Freezers for 3 years now with the promise that they are going to pave. Not going to happen! We have not been able to sleep at night or open our windows due to he noise and in the article they mention a noise bylaw from 7 p.m.to 7 a.m. Are they not part of Quinte West or are the Sidney Township laws not the same as ours?
Friday, March 26, 2010
Resident Update Submitted March 26
I entertained the thought of holding outdoor events at my own business down the road but after being outside yesterday and hearing the drone of noise even that far away I can't see any of them being interested in coming as most of them are environmentalists and would simply not enjoy the experience. I do have to chuckle a bit when I read the City's website. There is nothing friendly about it and wouldn't encourage anyone to move here. Thank goodness I am a destination store and my customers come from out of town.
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Resident Update Submitted 03/08/2010
Monday, March 1, 2010
A Resident Update
"The noise this past week at night is unbelievable. Although the windows are closed when you step out on the back porch of our house it really does sound like a jet taking off. Although that noise does not affect us inside the house as the direction it is facing is north, I can hardly wait for summer when we try to spend time outdoors. I figure it will be unbearable
We'll see."
Thursday, February 25, 2010
An Update
An amazing little drama unfolded a few weeks ago and I stepped back from the upkeep of this blog. Truth be told I considered taking the whole thing down but someone came forward and said it should remain. Long story short, updates and information can now be sent to citizen@socialtech.ca who will anonymously post on behalf of affected residents.
Anyway, enough time has passed to warrant an update so here it is...
We have received a letter written on behalf of John Gerretsen, Minister of the Environment. The letter states:
"... ministry staff from the Peterborough District office have been communicating with you about Canadian Blast Freezers (CBF) and are actively working to ensure the City of Quinte West and CBF resolve this noise issue."
"I can assure you that the ministry will continue to work, along with the city, to ensure that CBF undertakes the appropriate actions to mitigate the noise from their facility."
Holy mother of Saltine crackers! It only took six months and about a zillion messages to be assured that action of some sort will be taken.
For those of you who attended the meeting at Quinte West city hall, the document that the acoustic engineer said applied to this particular case is NPC-205, Sound Level Limits for Stationary Sources in Class 1 & 2 Areas (Urban) Of particular interest in this document is that aircraft noise is excluded when measuring background noise levels. This may be something to bring up with the engineer when the assessment is done.
Another update comes from the Midtown Meats union web page:
"Although we had requested to be allowed to visit the Trenton facility to ensure the Midtown Meats Ltd. Collective Agreement is not being violated, Mr. Willard has denied the request."
Hmmm.
Last, but not least, despite the fact that the Ministry of the Environment has sent assurances that the noise issue will be dealt with, and the city has hired an acoustic engineer to assess the situation, we've had enough. This entire ordeal has left us tired, miserable and worn. And so, we're putting this joint up for sale and starting the search for a house that we can make a home.
Oh, in case you were wondering, we will be voluntarily disclosing the noise issue to potential buyers.
Monday, January 25, 2010
The Meeting
One of the things that we were asked this evening was the times/days that the noise takes place. Here's the thing, there doesn't seem to be much rhyme or reason to when the noise occurs. Late at night, early evening, mid-morning, late afternoon... it's all over the place. What days? Again, there's no clear pattern that we can make out.
Today there was quite a bit of banging this morning, a bit of reefer noise, tomorrow there could be nothing at all, the next day reefers may run for hours on end. Some noise we don't hear at all but our neighbours will say they are disrupted. There are times we're faced with a great deal of noise that they can't hear. It really is difficult to pinpoint times and dates.
Meeting Day
I went to pay for my groceries yesterday and the transaction was declined, my account had been robbed. Given a short while to get over the initial shock of it, it really didn't bother me too much. What really blows me away is that my bank was notified that my account could be compromised and the issue was resolved fairly quickly. This noise issue, which is affecting the quality of life and well being of the people who live here, has been allowed to continue for over 2 years. I really feel that the noise bombardment from CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics is a far greater violation.
Today is the day we meet with the sound engineer. I wish I could be optimistic but our hopes for resolution have been dashed so many times before. I've become so accustomed to hearing "Sorry, nothing we can do about it" that I'm starting to expect it.
Thankfully that little round of noise has ended. Only a few minutes this time. Let's see how the rest of the day pans out.
Friday, January 22, 2010
Noise, noise, noise
When we left the house just before 5pm the noise had been rumbling on for hours. We've just arrived back home and it continues.
Today I got an email from Dalton McGuinty's office. They replied to let me know that they've asked John Gerretsen, Minister of the Environment, or a member of his staff, to respond to my concerns directly.
My concerns? I've been told by the Ministry of the Environment that under section 9 of the EPA Chill Chain Logistics/CB Freezers does not require any approval from MOE. I do not understand why section 14 does not apply to them.
Here's what I'm talking about...
Prohibition, discharge of contaminant 14. (1) Subject to subsection (2) but despite any other provision of this Act or the regulations, a person shall not discharge a contaminant or cause or permit the discharge of a contaminant into the natural environment, if the discharge causes or may cause an adverse effect. 2005, c. 12, s. 1 (5).
“contaminant” means any solid, liquid, gas, odour, heat, sound, vibration, radiation or combination of any of them resulting directly or indirectly from human activities that causes or may cause an adverse effect;
1. (1) In this Act, “adverse effect” means one or more of, (a) impairment of the quality of the natural environment for any use that can be made of it,(b) injury or damage to property or to plant or animal life,(c) harm or material discomfort to any person,(d) an adverse effect on the health of any person,(e) impairment of the safety of any person,(f) rendering any property or plant or animal life unfit for human use,(g) loss of enjoyment of normal use of property, and (h) interference with the normal conduct of business;
CB Freezers, Chill Chain Logistics have caused just about every 'adverse effect' on that list so why are they STILL allowed to continue. I'm looking forward to hearing what Mr. Gerretsen's office has to say about it.
Thursday, January 21, 2010
And here we go again.
This morning however reefers have been running continuously since at least 5:30 am. It's now 9:30. That's 4 hours of continuous noise from CB Freezers, noise coming from the Chill Chain Logistics refrigerated trailer units. When one turns off it only lessens the noise slightly because there are three of the things parked there and turned on.
As soon as I finish up some work I'm spending the day in the basement in the hopes of escaping this bombardment.
Wednesday, January 20, 2010
Our Lucky Day
I guess we won't have a repeat of the 10 hour marathon.
I won't be holding my breath that the silence will last.
One Hour
I listened to hours upon hours of banging today. Banging so loud it sounded like road construction when they break up the old paving. Now the drone of a Chill Chain Logistics reefer.
It used to be that at least there was some peace during the day. Not any more.
Just in time...
They've been banging about the entire day and now the night will be marked by the noise from the reefer that is parked in the front loading area of CB Freezers.
Sweet dreams indeed.
Tuesday, January 19, 2010
Death as an option.
Monday afternoon brought a city representative to my door. She was dropping off a notice to residents about the meeting with the sound engineer on Monday the 25th. I asked her what we were to do in the meantime. She replied "I'm just the messenger."
She asked if I was the one with the blog and if I could really hear the noise from inside my house. I answered 'yes' and got upset. I'm not really a crier but I find I can't control it anymore. The tears automatically begin to flow because I'm so tired and frustrated and no one seems to give a shit that we are suffering.
"This is really affecting you huh?" she asks. I assume she doesn't know that I've asked the Ministry of the Environment if someone needs to cause themselves bodily harm in order for someone to take action... I'm certain she doesn't know that a resident has offered to do it.
New neighbours should be talking about the weather, not about death as an option for dealing with noise contamination. The thing is that my neighbour is not alone. I've been in my home, listening to the droning noise coming from CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics and thought "If I were dead I wouldn't have to listen to this anymore." But here's the thing... I don't want to die, I love life, I love my family, I love making the most out of what I have... it's an uncontrollable thought that pops into my head because there is no other choice. They will not stop and no one will stop them.
CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics does not make medicine, they do not ship organs for transplant, they are not feeding starving masses, their businesses do not better the world. We are suffering because of frozen meat meant to be shipped to China and Russia. We are suffering so that they can make money at the expense of our health, sanity and quality of life.
Sunday, January 17, 2010
Have a nice weekend...
On Saturday at 3:30 in the afternoon a reefer was parked in the front docking bay, directly across from our house, and left running. Despite assurances that the reefers would be kept in the West lot, there are also four reefers in the East lot... two of those have been left on.
My husband has been awake since 3:30 a.m. because of this noise. This noise is directly caused by CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics. CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics has disrupted normal family activities in our home. The actions of CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics has disrupted our sleep, has been the direct cause of health issues, has been the direct cause of mood changes, has been the direct cause of stress of such levels that I was placed on sick leave from work, it is the direct cause of being medicated for these stress and sleep issues.
I need to be medicated so that I can live in my own home because of CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics.
We are not the only household in this neighbourhood requiring 'aids' in order to sleep in our own homes and keep our sanity intact. I personally know of two other households using aids in order to sleep because of the problems brought on by CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics.
We are not the only household whose health and quality of life are diminished as a direct cause of Chill Chain Logistics/CB Freezers. Representatives from any of the Willard family companies can tell me whatever they like but many people in this community feel that CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics are directly responsible for their health and quality of life issues.
And yet our 'good neighbours' continue to bombard us with noise. CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logistics and the Willard family companies, continue to disrupt our lives and our sleep and effect our health. Do they really care about this neighbourhood? I don't believe they do for a second.
Monday, January 11, 2010
A not so quiet Sunday dinner.
I know that CB Freezers/Chill Chain Logisitics keeps doling out the 'we want to be good neighbours' thing but really... if I woke my neighbours up and was this disruptive to other peoples lives you can be certain that someone would put a stop to the un-neighbourly behaviour.
My husband spoke with Gary Dyke, Chief Administrative Officer of Quinte West, this morning and we have an update:
"... the City has engaged Coulter and Associates to conduct an engineering study with respect to the issues raised regarding CB Freezers.
A date has been arranged whereby John Coulter will meet with the concerned residents to receive their input directly. The meeting will be held on Monday January 25th at 6:00 pm in the Multi-purpose Room (downstairs to the left of the stairs) at City Hall. If you could forward this information to the rest of the neighbours who attended the earlier meeting with Councillor Alyea, it would be greatly appreciated."
We'll be there with bells on.
Tuesday, January 5, 2010
Here we go again.
We've been told that the running reefers would be kept in the West lot... obviously this did not happen last night.
As I mentioned in my last post, the company claims they want to be good neighbours... this obviously didn't happen last night either.